elf liquid liners-only metallics/glitter review

 stardust, copper(which is really gold), silver $1

these rub-proof to a certain degree, and i doubt they're waterproof(i didn't test that). these do have good color pay off and the stardust is good as a layering liner over colors. these don't tend to peel like the nyx crystal glitter liners. the silver does need a second coat to get any spots. the brush may get stray hairs, but you can push those back in by putting product on it. it also has a stopper, so you don't get gobs of glitter on your face. for $1, i would recommend since it's cheap but also works. now elf, make a white please. :D